It’s winter, and the pump track is calling.
The ground is cold, the air is crisp, and that familiar rhythm of wheels is calling to you like an old lover’s whisper.
But wait – should you hit the track on your trusty BMX, or should you go with something a bit more technologically advanced, a bit more suspension-happy – like a dirt jumper?
Decisions, decisions….
Get ready for some hard truths – and a couple of laughs along the way.
1. Wheel Size – Small and Snappy vs. Big and Beefy
First thing’s first: let’s talk about wheels.
BMX bikes are like that old classic car, small, agile, and built for speed. The typical BMX on a pump track runs on a 20” wheel – fast, nimble, and as responsive as a caffeinated squirrel.
You can easily jump into corners, pop, and whip around without much effort. The bike’s smaller, and so are the wheels – perfect for quick changes in direction.
On the other hand, dirt jumpers tend to roll on bigger wheels – typically 26” – which means they’re built to handle more rugged terrain.
This means more stability, but at the cost of agility.
Dirt jumpers are great for bigger jumps and gnarlier trails, but if you’re on a pump track, the extra heft of the wheels might feel like dragging a log through molasses.
| Bike Type | Wheel Size | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|---|
| BMX | 20” | Fast, nimble, responsive | Less stable at higher speeds |
| Dirt Jumper | 26” | Stable, good for jumps | Slower to react, less agile |
2. Suspension – The Secret to Comfort (Or Not)
Now, let’s talk suspension. BMX bikes? They’re rigid. No fancy shock absorbers here, just metal and rubber – straight to the point. BMX riders rely on their skill to absorb impacts, using their body like a shock absorber. If you’ve got a 20” BMX, it’s like the bike is telling you, “We’re here to go fast, not to pamper you.”
Dirt jumpers, however, are a different breed. These bikes have suspension forks, often with around 100mm of travel. Translation: they give you a bit more cushion for those gnarly landings or when the track gets a little rough. But let’s not kid ourselves. The suspension’s not going to turn a bad jump into a soft landing. It just helps you feel a little less beaten up after a long session.
| Bike Type | Suspension | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|---|
| BMX | Rigid | Simple, lightweight | Harder on the body, less forgiving |
| Dirt Jumper | 100mm Fork | More comfortable, better for bigger jumps | Adds weight, less agile |
3. The Feel – Playful vs. Versatile
When you hop on a BMX, it’s like stepping into a world of controlled chaos. The smaller wheels and rigid frame make it playful, responsive, and quick to react. It’s all about the snap – whether it’s a pump or a jump, you can feel every ounce of energy transfer right into the dirt. If you want to pop off the lip of a jump and do a quick 180, BMX is your friend.
Dirt jumpers, however, offer a different experience. With longer frames and slacker geometry, they’re built for versatility. You’re less likely to feel that ‘snap’ but more likely to feel stable, balanced, and in control when you take on a set of berms or double jumps.
They’re more forgiving, especially if you want to hit the dirt a little harder and still keep rolling. But at the same time, dirt jumpers might not have that zippy feeling that a BMX gives you when it’s time to whip around a corner.
| Bike Type | Feel | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|---|
| BMX | Playful | Quick, snappy, fun | Less stable at speed |
| Dirt Jumper | Versatile | Stable, balanced, forgiving | Less responsive, slower handling |
4. Weight – Lightweight King vs. The Heavyweight Champion
This is where BMX really shines. Weighing in at a fraction of the weight of a dirt jumper, a BMX bike is easy to toss around. Think of it as the featherweight boxer of the pump track world. It’s the perfect bike for those moments when you need to throw your bike around mid-air or snap out of a corner with speed.
Now, dirt jumpers… They’re more like the heavyweight champ. Sure, they’ve got more weight to them, but that extra heft comes with added stability and strength. They’re built to handle the stress of dirt jumps, landing hard, and bouncing over obstacles. However, that extra weight could slow you down when it’s time to pump through the track and gain momentum.
| Bike Type | Weight | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|---|
| BMX | Lightweight | Quick to maneuver, faster | Less stable at speed |
| Dirt Jumper | Heavier | Stronger, more stable | Slower to accelerate |
5. Cost in the Long Run
Let’s not pretend. BMX bikes are cheap. Well, cheaper than dirt jumpers, anyway. You could spend a fraction of what a dirt jumper costs and still have a bike that rips on the pump track.
BMX bikes are durable, they’re simple, and the parts are easy to replace. So, if you’re looking for pure performance without breaking the bank, BMX is the way to go.
Dirt jumpers, though, come with a price tag. They’re specialized bikes, designed for dirt jumping, big drops, and rough terrains. If you want a good dirt jumper, you’re going to spend a pretty penny. And with that price, you get more advanced suspension, stronger frames, and generally better performance on more varied terrains.
| Bike Type | Cost | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|---|
| BMX | Affordable | Inexpensive, easy to maintain | Limited to flat or small jumps |
| Dirt Jumper | Expensive | High performance, good for varied terrains | Expensive, higher maintenance |
Conclusion:
So here’s the deal. If you’re looking for something light, quick, and responsive for those tight pump track sessions, BMX is your friend. It’s the kind of bike that makes you feel like you’re the king of the track, even if you’re still working on your first barspin.
Dirt jumpers? They’re the sturdy, more comfortable, and versatile option – but let’s be real, they’re not the pump track machine. They’ll give you a smoother ride, but they’re going to feel like you’re lugging a bag of bricks through a race.
At the end of the day, it’s not about which one’s better. It’s about what feels right. Want to feel like a hero flying through the air? Go BMX. Want to feel like the rugged warrior who’s just done battle with gravity? Go dirt jumper. Either way, the pump track’s waiting.
And remember: when in doubt, just pedal harder.
Danny G.
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.